I’m not going to review Scott Pilgrim vs. The World fully, mostly because I’m in no mood to spend a few hours articulating my thoughts ideally (I’m still in “minimize online time as much as possible” mode). Instead, I’ll crib a style from one of my contemporaries, namely Josh Loomis over at www.BlueInkAlchemy.com, and jot down a few thoughts in categorized bullet points.
Behold the awesome power (and flaming katana) of Self-Respect!
Stuff I didn’t like:
- Michael Cera. I know it’s terribly redundant and borderline damaging to my credibility to bring up his type-casting affliction, but it’s hard not to be ticked off at this particular actor when he’s the only reason the Arrested Development movie hasn’t happened yet, and probably never will. His idea of diversifying himself as an actor is to play subtle spins on his claim to fame. Superbad, Juno, Nick and Norah’s Infinite Playlist, Youth in Revolt, and Scott Pilgrim vs. The World don’t just have Michael Cera in common; they have George Michael Bluth in common. I suppose after playing the same character in every movie, you do eventually get pretty darn good at it, and to Cera’s credit, he’s got the awkward stammering teenager-twentysomething model polished to a mirror shine. I just with that Cera would stop lying to us.
- The music. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is under the impression that the noble spirit of counter culture will captivate us into feeling sympathetic for the gritty nerd rock trio around whom the movie revolves simply because their underdog struggle is endearing. This doesn’t work. I understand that the movie is trying to create this sort of raw and organic edge, but it just comes off as terribly brash and vulgar. There are occasional successful glimmers of the aural appeal the filmmakers are trying to recreate, but these come from the opponents of the protagonist trio and not the trio themselves.
- Mary Elizabeth Winstead. It’s not so much the fact that such a beautiful actress had to have washed her hair with different lurid oil paints every week and go for days without sleep for the part of Ramona Flowers, but more the fact that the character for whom she does this is utterly useless. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is trying to make comments on the dynamics of adolescent and young adult love, but by the end of the film, I wasn’t entirely sure what these comments were supposed to be. Aspire to be good enough for the moment to your partner? The integrity of one partner is more important than the integrity of the relationship? Always fear the repercussions of wronged lovers? None of these are particularly encouraging, and perhaps the ultimate goal was the examination of the futility of meaningful companionship in a world where everything is fickle and superficial (such as Toronto). Like I said, I’m not entirely sure, and the muddied morals, however much intended they may be, diminish the product.
- The length: While Scott Pilgrim vs. The World clocks in at under two hours, the gambit to stage the ending twice (courteous of Scott Pilgrim’s extra life), brisk though it may be, bloats the entire film. In fact the initial set up is so leisurely that it becomes at odds with the double conclusion, and an overall imbalance between the acts results. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World comes to a rather resolute end, yet endeavours to drag itself to the closing credits 15 some minutes later.
“Her?”
Stuff I liked:
- The sound design. While I never cared particularly much for the performed music, largely because it celebrates asinine pretension over anything remotely tangible, the overall sound design was rather inspired. Dozens of soundbytes and clips from iconic pillars of nerd culture are liberally sprinkled throughout the film, and this sort of trivial interaction was a nice secondary level to enjoy when certain character vulgarities dominated. The foley artistry required for the bombastic fight scenes was also nuanced and detailed.
- The supporting cast. Kieran Culkin and his arsenal of gay boy toys have some of the best comic timing of any North American comic actor you care to name, Allison Pill sports a phenomenal deadpan, and Ellen Wong as the remarkably zealous Knives Chau has an unbelievably wide range of spontaneously energetic demeanours. And this is without mentioning the always delightful Anna Kendrick and truly surreal fight scene between George Michael Bluth and Anne Veal (Mae Whitman). The leads are largely bland and uninteresting, but everyone else is absolutely stellar.
- The cinematography. Director Edgar Wright and company have always had a talent for squeezing the most out of every shot and setpiece, and Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is no exception. The deliberate assembly of sequences that enables a single brief conversation to take place between several disparate locations without compromising pace and fluency is inspiring, and the sharply vibrant colour palettes make even the utterly useless scenes (of which there are many) visual treats. I was even pleasantly surprised by the skillful action choreography, where nimble adversaries dance circles around a disoriented Scott, yet the camera is always there to capture it coherently with lingering shots and few cuts.
- The Vegan Police.
Being familiar with the work of Edgar Wright, this scene was probably intended to remind me of Kung Fu Hustle
Conclusion: Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is certainly the most faithful comic book adaptation, if only because it goes to such great lengths to transplant the comic stylings to film. Unfortunately, unparalleled fidelity doesn’t automatically make a great movie. What works as a comic does not always work well as a film, and Scott Pilgrim vs. The World exemplifies this to the same extent that it exemplifies how it’s possible to take every conceivable comic flourish and paste it to celluloid. So while it’s kinetic and imaginative, it’s also brash and vulgar. Scott Pilgrim vs. The World is indeed refined where it matters most, with the flaws likely exposed so that its imperfect nature might endear itself further. A risky picture sure to earn adulation from the crowd to which it’s catering, but almost certainly unintelligible to everyone else.
Aside: If anyone should like Scott Pilgrim vs. The World, it should probably be me. I live in Toronto, enjoy video games, music, and movies, and could easily be classified as a nerd, despite my preference for being uncategorized. Curious…

This is a Toronto sunrise (apparently). I’ve actually been awake for a few of these this summer, which is rather unprecedented.
Summon guardian spirits to battle evil shadow demons by committing suicide!


